A nice idea, but . . .

Toronto’s Pearson Intl. Airport wants to build a massive transit hub on adjacent land.

The hub, which would cost billions, would tie together GO Transit, the Toronto region’s commuter train service; UP Express, a newly opened rail link between Pearson and Toronto’s Union Station; the bus service for the city of Mississauga, a growing bedroom suburb on Toronto’s western flank; streetcar lines and maybe even a high-speed rail link.

Union Station West

What Pearson’s new transportation hub would look like

Support for the new transit hub, dubbed Union Station West, is growing, reports the Toronto Star, which says the Canadian government is now giving the project serious consideration. Ditto for Ontario.

Yet, the folks in the planning department would do well to cast their eyes eastward to Pickering, a rapidly growing bedroom city on Toronto’s eastern flank. There, pressure is building for the Canadian government to dust off its decades-old plan to construct an airport to serve that region. And if it does, it would only make sense to pair the airport with a transportation hub similar to the one Pearson now wants to build

True, Nimbyism killed the Pickering airport years ago. But Pearson’s growing throughput may yet make a new airport a reality. After all, it’s unlikely that Pearson, which last year handled a record 40 million passengers, will lay down any new runways in the near future. Moreover, travellers who live in the Pickering area may be increasingly reluctant to drive all the way across the top of Toronto just to catch a flight..

Advertisements

A Great Idea. But Will it Ever Get on Track?

Want to know why some passenger trains have been such a hit? They run on dedicated rights of way.  No sitting in sidings waiting for 150-car freight trains to rumble by. No commuter trains to hopscotch around.  Just passenger trains. And if the right of way is custom-built for high speed, so much the better.

Small wonder that Via Rail, Canada’s version of Amtrak, wants to get its own tracks between Montreal, Ottawa and Toronto– lines it must share with Canadian National Railways, as well as with the commuter services in Canada’s two biggest cities.

But the exclusive right of way may be a long time in coming. The main reason? The high price tag: C$4 billion. At a time when the Canadian government is chary of coughing up billions of dollars to help Toronto expand its subway, it’s a good bet it won’t want to cough up even more money for Via Rail, a federally funded operation.

Then, too, where will Via build its right of way? The logical choice would seem to be alongside CN Rail’s existing main line since it serves more populated areas than the Montreal-Toronto line operated by rival Canadian Pacific06-05-VIA-673x427 (1).

But simply putting down another two tracks besides CN’s double-track line would be daunting. Overpasses, as well as bridges, would have to be widened. And finding space along the existing rights of way into both Toronto and Montreal would be hard.

Still, Via’s proposal is a gambit to stir the blood! Stay tuned!